County inexplicably halts negotiations to preserve the Old Jail

Architectural Preservation Foundation of Contra Costa County (APFCCC) Press Release

The Contra Costa County Administrator’s office abruptly terminated negotiations that assured preservation of the Historic Old Jail in Martinez, and concurrently slated the building for demolition.  The Historic Old Jail was built in 1903 and is designated on the National Register of Historic Places because it represents classically inspired early 20th Century public buildings and, along with the Courthouse, was Contra Costa County’s first major government headquarters.  It was built of Vermont granite block “to last far into the future to express Contra Costa’s pride and confidence.” The Historic Old Jail is 118 years old.

Four Years of  City of Martinez and Citizen Efforts to Save the Jail

The County first proposed demolishing the Old Jail in 2017 in order to replace it with nine parking spaces.  There was considerable public outcry and lawsuit filed by Architectural Preservation Foundation of Contra Costa County (APFCCC) challenging the County’s action.

Within a few months of filing the lawsuit, negotiations between the County, the APFCCC, the City and a historic preservation developer began to hammer out a mutually acceptable solution.  Over four years, the parties’ efforts progressed towards a viable plan to preserve and reuse the Old Jail and few details remained.  On January 26, 2021, the Board of Supervisors reviewed the final drawings confirming the preservation of Historic Old Jail.  

County Jettison’s Jail Preservation Plan in Closed-Door Meeting

One week later, February 2, the Board held a closed-door meeting to discuss the Historic Old Jail.  Immediately after that meeting, the County terminated negotiations with the City, offering no clue as to why the County rejected the settlement.  The City and APFCCC were shocked by this action. 

The Board of Supervisor’s agenda for Tuesday, February 9, now proposes to demolish both the 12-story building and the Old Jail.  There have been no public hearings on the demolition, or on the County Administrator’s proposed construction of the new offices at 651 Pine Street with a price tag of $65-$75 million dollars.  The Board of Supervisors will discuss both the demolition and the new construction at Tuesday’s meeting. 

Countless hours by County and City Staff and APFCCC were expended on the effort to produce a viable plan to preserve and reuse the Historic Old Jail.  The citizens of Martinez are entitled to answers as to why the County is abandoning this four-year effort.   Cheryll Grover, President of the Foundation says “We encourage citizens to speak up now. It’s getting harder to be “heard” when meetings are no longer in person. Too many bad things can happen out of the public eye.”

2 Replies to “County inexplicably halts negotiations to preserve the Old Jail

  1. NOW IS THE TIME! 100 year old historic buildings have 30,000 sq ft of USABLE SPACE! The rubble from these two and the skyscraper across the street will release asbestos in the surrounding neighborhoods for years to come! Sometimes we need to learn to leave sleeping dogs lie and USE THEM! Repurpose them as the strongest standing structures in this City! The need is GREAT! ~

  2. Board of Supervisors will go wherever the money is. We saw this when they were shuttering a library (pleasant hill) for school children – in favor of a developer (and likely checks under the table) this is the grease that turns the wheels in Contra Costa County. Corruption.

    The historic buildings on the society list are meant to be preserved, but when a check comes waiving shut door meetings ensue. Big money developers always win out – against public interests – and it’s not because they have pretty construction boots.


    *Find US on Facebook group: California Family Advocacy*

    Vote out all of the Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *